Hawaii Accidents

FAQ | Glossary | Topics
ES EN

Why does Hilo insurance get to pick the doctor after my deer crash?

They do not get the final say on your injuries, and you need to push back fast before benefits get cut off.

  1. The insurance doctor is not your treating doctor. If the insurer sends you to an independent medical exam (IME) after a Hilo crash, that doctor is usually there to give the insurer an opinion, not to manage your care. In Hawaii, your own auto policy's Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage often pays the first $10,000 in medical benefits after a car accident, even if nobody is blaming you yet. The insurer may use an IME to say treatment should stop early.

  2. You can get your own doctor's opinion right now. If you swerved for a deer on Saddle Road, Highway 11, or another Big Island route and got hurt, make an appointment with your own physician, urgent care, orthopedic doctor, or physical therapist as soon as possible. Ask for clear notes on diagnosis, work limits, pain, and why treatment is still needed. That record can matter more than one short insurance exam.

  3. Do not miss deadlines or stop treatment without a written reason. If the insurer denies more care, ask for the denial in writing and save every letter, text, and explanation of benefits. Gaps in treatment can be used against you. If your crash involved another driver, Hawaii's general deadline to file a personal injury lawsuit is usually 2 years from the accident date.

  4. Your crash report and medical timeline need to match. If Hawaii Police Department responded in Hilo, get the report number and check that the facts line up with what your doctors are documenting. If the insurer says you were barely hurt but your ER visit, follow-up care, and missed work show otherwise, that inconsistency matters.

  5. If your lawyer is doing nothing, you can switch. You are not trapped. If your current lawyer will not explain the IME, PIP cutoff, or next deadlines, you can move your file. Do that before records go stale, surveillance starts, or the 2-year clock gets too close.

by Keoni Makoa on 2026-03-22

Nothing on this page should be taken as legal advice — it's general information that may not apply to your specific case. If you've been hurt, a lawyer can tell you where you actually stand.

Get a free case review →
← All FAQs Home